MarketPulse checklist
Ecommerce Vendor Comparison Checklist
For comparing software: platforms, apps, plugins and tools. Fees per order, data you can take with you, clashes with your theme, real support hours and a trial that tests something.
Software is cheap to install and expensive to leave.
This ecommerce vendor comparison checklist is for choosing software: the store platform itself, or an app, plugin or connected tool for reviews, preorders, shipping labels, stock sync or email. It assumes you already know which job the software must do. If you have not got that far, the ecommerce software buying brief helps you write the job down first.
Comparing people you could hire is a different exercise, with different questions; for that, use the discovery call scorecard and the quote comparison method. Software vendors get judged on fees at your volume, what happens to your data when you leave, how the tool behaves next to your other tools, and who answers when it breaks on a Saturday.
How do you compare pricing tiers and per-order fees?
Monthly plan prices are the number on the pricing page, and at real order volumes they are frequently the smaller part of the bill. Work out the cost at your own monthly order count, using the vendor’s listed rates.
Here is what that looks like with the platform’s own numbers. Shopify’s pricing page (checked November 2026, euro prices as shown for the Netherlands; prices differ by country) lists, when paying monthly:
| Entry plan (cheapest listed) | Grow plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Plan price, billed monthly | €28 a month | €78 a month |
| Online standard card rate with Shopify Payments | 1.9% + €0.25 | 1.8% + €0.25 |
| Third-party transaction fee, if you use another payment provider | 2% | 1% |
Worked example for a shop with 400 online orders a month at an average of €35, paying by standard card through Shopify Payments:
- Entry plan: 400 × (1.9% × €35 + €0.25) = 400 × €0.915 = €366 in card fees, plus €28 = €394 a month.
- Grow plan: 400 × (1.8% × €35 + €0.25) = 400 × €0.88 = €352 in card fees, plus €78 = €430 a month.
- The two meet where 0.035 × orders = €50, at about 1,430 orders a month at that average order value. Below it, the cheaper plan wins on fees alone.
Amex and international cards carry higher listed rates, so treat this as the floor. If you kept a different payment provider, the entry plan’s 2% third-party fee would add 400 × €35 × 2% = €280 a month, before that provider’s own charges.
Apps follow the same logic. Shopify App Store apps bill through Shopify, and Shopify’s app billing documentation says the charges land on the merchant’s Shopify invoice and can be recurring or usage-based. Compare two invented preorder apps (example prices): App X costs €19 a month up to 100 orders and €49 a month above that; App Y costs €9 a month plus €0.10 per order. At 250 orders, X costs €49 and Y costs 9 + 25 = €34. The two meet at 400 orders (9 + 0.10 × 400 = 49), and above that X is cheaper. Run the sum at your volume and at your busiest month.
Can you get your data out, and in what shape?
Lock-in rarely shows on day one. It shows the day you want to leave and find that your reviews, subscriptions or customer notes only exist inside one vendor’s system. Test the exit before you depend on the tool:
- Ask for an export in writing: which data, which file format, and whether it includes history (all reviews with dates and photos, all past orders, all customer tags).
- Run the export during the trial and open the file. A CSV with columns you can read beats a promise.
- Check the platform side too. WooCommerce ships with a built-in tool for importing, exporting and bulk-updating products as CSV, described in the Product CSV Importer and Exporter guide. The WooCommerce REST API documentation lists endpoints for orders, products, customers and coupons, which is how a developer moves data that no export button covers.
- Ask what stays behind when you cancel. Widgets, shortcodes, scripts or theme files the tool added need removing, and the vendor should tell you how.
Lock-in signs to write down: no export at all, export only on the most expensive tier, exports by support request only, or data stored in a format only that vendor reads.
Will the app clash with your theme or your other apps?
Most “the shop broke” calls after installing an app come down to two causes: the app changed theme code, or two apps tried to control the same part of the page.
On Shopify, ask whether the app uses theme app extensions (app blocks you place in the theme editor). Shopify’s theme app extensions documentation says apps built this way do not edit theme code, which lowers the risk of breaking the theme. An app that asks to edit theme files directly needs a test on a copy of your theme first.
For clashes between tools, check these before installing:
- Overlap. Two apps that both change the cart, both add a popup, or both send order emails will fight. List what each installed tool already does.
- Stock and order sync. If a till system, a marketplace connector and the new tool all write stock numbers, decide which one is the source of truth before going live.
- Connection method. Ask which permissions the app requests and whether it connects through the platform’s official API. On WooCommerce, ask which plugin versions and WooCommerce versions it has been tested with.
- Speed. Load your product page on a phone before and after installing. If it feels slower, test again with the app switched off.
What support will you actually get, and when?
Support only matters on the day something breaks, so check it as if that day has come:
- Channels: email, chat, phone, a forum, or documentation only.
- Hours and time zone: “24/7” on the listing, or office hours in a time zone eight hours from yours?
- Response time in writing: a stated first-response time, and whether a weekend outage counts.
- Who answers: the developer of the app, a support team, or a community forum.
For WordPress plugins, the plugin’s page on WordPress.org shows when it was last updated, how many active installations it has, the WordPress version it was tested up to, and how many support issues were resolved in the last two months (see the WooCommerce plugin page for where those fields sit). A plugin last updated long ago, or with few resolved issues, is a support warning before you have asked anything.
Then test it: send one real question during your trial, on a weekday afternoon, and time the answer.
How do you run a 14-day trial that proves something?
A trial where you click around for ten minutes proves the demo works. Use the days instead:
| Day | Test | Pass if |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Install on a copy of your theme or a staging copy of the shop. | The live shop is untouched. |
| 2 | Set it up with 20 of your real products, including ones with options. | Setup takes under two hours without support. |
| 3 to 6 | Place test orders through the full flow, on a phone. | Orders, emails and stock all come out right. |
| 7 | Send a real question to support. | A useful answer within the stated time. |
| 8 to 10 | Run it next to your other apps; check page speed. | No clashes, no visible slowdown. |
| 11 | Export everything the tool holds. | A readable file with full history. |
| 12 | Uninstall it from the copy. | Nothing left behind, or clear removal steps. |
| 13 to 14 | Price it at your volume and your busiest month. | The cost fits the budget at peak. |
Some vendors give you no free trial. Shopify’s App Store requirements ask developers to list free-trial time and charge details in an app’s pricing information, so check the listing first. For paid extensions from the WooCommerce.com Marketplace, the WooCommerce refund policy offers a full refund within 30 days of purchase, which gives you a window to run this plan.
How do you read app store reviews?
Star averages hide the reviews that matter to you. Shopify’s App Store requirements forbid fake and incentivized reviews, which helps, and you still need to read them with a method:
- Sort by newest. A tool that was good two years ago and has since been sold or neglected shows it in recent reviews first.
- Read the 1 to 3 star reviews. Look for patterns: billing surprises, lost data, slow support. One angry review is noise; five reviews about the same problem are a fact.
- Read the developer’s replies. A specific answer that fixes the problem is a better sign than a high average with no replies.
- Find reviews from shops like yours. A 5-star review from a shop with 20 orders a month says little about how the tool handles 2,000.
- Search reviews for your must-have feature by name, and check whether anyone mentions it working.
What is on the full vendor comparison checklist?
Score each line pass or fail for each vendor. Any fail on the first four lines is a reason to stop, whatever the other results.
| # | Check | How to check it | Pass rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Does the job on your real products | Trial days 2 to 6 | Works with options and test orders |
| 2 | Full data export | Trial day 11 | Readable file, full history |
| 3 | Cost at your volume and at peak | Arithmetic from listed rates | Inside budget at your busiest month |
| 4 | No clash with theme or other apps | Trial days 8 to 10 | No errors, no slowdown |
| 5 | Clean uninstall | Trial day 12 | Nothing left, or written removal steps |
| 6 | Support answers in time | Trial day 7 | Useful reply within the stated time |
| 7 | Support hours fit yours | Listing and terms | Covers your trading hours |
| 8 | Recent reviews | Newest-first reading | No repeated serious complaint |
| 9 | Active maintenance | Last update, changelog | Updated in the last few months |
| 10 | Plan changes without a call | Listing and billing page | Upgrade or downgrade from the admin |
| 11 | Permissions match the job | Install screen | No access it does not need |
| 12 | Cancellation terms | Terms page | Monthly cancel, or a refund window |
Line 10 has a Shopify basis: the App Store requirements say an app must let merchants upgrade and downgrade their pricing plan without contacting support or reinstalling. Outside Shopify, check it yourself.
How do you decide between two finalists?
Example only. A garden center trials two invented click-and-collect slot apps. App X passes 11 of 12 lines and fails line 7 (support only in a time zone six hours away). App Y passes 10 and fails lines 2 and 9: exports leave out past bookings, and the last update was over a year ago.
App Y is €10 a month cheaper. It still loses, because a failed export is a fail on the first four lines, and that rule stands before price. The garden center takes App X and writes down a workaround for line 7: urgent questions go in before noon local time.
Two more rules help at this stage. Keep a one-page record of the chosen tool: what it does, what it costs at your volume, how to export, how to cancel. And set a review date six months out, when you re-run lines 3, 8 and 9. Tools change owners, prices and support levels, and the checklist only stays true if you look again.
FAQ
How many apps should I trial at once?
Two per job, never more. With three or more, test orders and support questions overlap and you lose track of which tool caused what. Trial different jobs one after another, so a clash has one suspect.
Is a free app safer than a paid one?
A free price says nothing about safety. Check the same twelve lines. Free tools still need exports, support and maintenance, and some make their money by moving you to a paid tier once you depend on them.
What if a vendor has no export?
Treat it as a fail on line 2 unless the data is throwaway, such as a countdown banner. For anything holding customer content, orders or reviews, choose a tool you can leave.
Should my developer choose the apps?
Your developer can shortlist and test, and you should still see the cost at your volume and the export test yourself. Ask them to fill in the checklist table and say whether they earn a commission on any recommended tool.
Does this checklist work for choosing the platform itself?
Yes, with heavier weight on lines 2, 3 and 12, since leaving a platform is a migration. For the platform choice for a shop with a counter, read Shopify vs WooCommerce for local business, and before moving an existing shop, the migration questions.
Are annual plans worth the discount?
Only after the tool has passed a full month of real use. Before that, pay monthly. If a vendor offers only annual billing, look for a refund window in the terms and run the trial plan inside it.
How do I find out what an app will leave behind?
Ask the vendor before installing, then check during the trial by uninstalling it from a copy of your theme or a staging copy of the shop and looking for leftover blocks, scripts or settings.
What should you check first?
Start with the two sums that change minds most: the cost at your real order volume, and the export test. Both take under an hour and knock out more vendors than any feature list.
If you are torn between two tools, or between a tool and hiring someone to build the feature, describe the job through the MarketPulse contact form and we will help you set up the comparison.
More on buying ecommerce software
Decide the job first, then compare the tools that could do it.