A local pickup and delivery setup starts with a business decision long before anyone touches the shipping settings: which ways of getting an order into a nearby customer’s hands will you offer, and at what price? Most small stores choose by copying a competitor’s checkout. That leads to a van that runs half empty, a pickup counter nobody staffs on Saturdays, or a same-day app that takes the margin on every basket.

This page compares the four local options on cost per order, product fit and staff load, with a worked example you can redo with your own numbers. Once you know which options to offer, the set-up guides take over: delivery zones and fees, click and collect and stock by location.

Which local fulfillment options can a small store offer?

Four options cover almost every local store. They differ in who carries the order and who pays for the time.

OptionWho carries the orderYour main costCustomer gets
Pickup (in store or at the curb)The customerPicking, packing, a holding shelf, handover timeNo fee in most shops, collection at a time that suits them
Own deliveryYour staff, your vehicleDriver hours, vehicle running costsA delivery day and window you control
Local courierA parcel or courier companyA per-parcel rate, packagingTheir delivery times, their tracking
Same-day appThe app’s driversCommission or per-order fee set in your contractFast delivery, inside the app or via your site

Both big platforms support the first two out of the box. Shopify’s delivery methods help describes local delivery to addresses within a set distance or to listed postal codes, pickup in store at your retail locations, and pickup points (third-party lockers and post offices) for stores in France, Italy, Spain and the UK. WooCommerce handles local delivery through shipping zones limited to specific postal codes, and has a Local Pickup setting for the Checkout block with one or more pickup locations. So the platform rarely limits the choice. Your costs and your staff do.

What does each option cost per order?

Example shop: a deli with 120 products and an average local order of $48. Gross margin is 35%, so an average order leaves $16.80 before fulfillment. These figures are assumptions for the example. Replace each one with your own wage rate, vehicle cost and courier quote.

LineAssumption
Staff cost$18 an hour, so $0.30 a minute
Pick and pack, one order6 minutes = $1.80
Pickup handover3 minutes = $0.90
Bag or box$0.30 for pickup, $0.80 for delivery, $1.20 for a courier box with padding
Van evening run3 hours of driver time ($54) plus 40 miles at an assumed $0.70 running cost per mile ($28)
Courier quote$7.50 per parcel (example quote)
Same-day app25% commission on the order value (example contract)

The arithmetic

  • Pickup: $1.80 + $0.90 + $0.30 = $3.00 per order.
  • Own van, 12 drops a run: run cost $54 + $28 = $82, divided by 12 = $6.83, plus packing $1.80 and box $0.80 = $9.43 per order.
  • Courier: $7.50 + $1.80 + $1.20 = $10.50 per order.
  • Same-day app: 25% of $48 = $12.00, plus packing $1.80 = $13.80 per order.
OptionCost per orderMargin left from $16.80
Pickup$3.00$13.80
Own van, 12 drops$9.43$7.37
Courier$10.50$6.30
Same-day app$13.80$3.00

The table already says something most owners miss: on a $48 basket, a percentage-based app keeps more than the delivery itself costs you to run, and pickup leaves more than four times the margin of the app. A delivery fee charged to the customer changes the picture, which the zones guide works through zone by zone.

Why does the number of drops decide whether your own van pays?

Own delivery has a fixed cost per run and a small cost per order. That makes it the only option whose cost per order falls as you get busier, and rises sharply on quiet days.

Drops on the runRun cost per order ($82 / drops)Plus packing and box ($2.60)Cost per order
4$20.50$2.60$23.10
6$13.67$2.60$16.27
12$6.83$2.60$9.43
20$4.10$2.60$6.70

At 6 drops, the deli spends $16.27 to deliver an order that earns $16.80. At 20 drops, the same van is cheaper than the courier. The break-even comes from one line of arithmetic. If the customer pays a $5 delivery fee, each delivered order brings in $16.80 plus $5.00 minus $2.60 = $19.20 toward the run. The run costs $82, and $82 / $19.20 = 4.3, so the deli needs at least 5 orders on a run to cover it.

The practical rule: fix delivery days so orders pile up on the same run. Two runs a week with 10 drops each cost far less per order than five daily runs with 4 drops each, and customers accept a set day when the checkout says so clearly.

Which options fit which products and order values?

Cost is half the decision. The product decides the other half: a chilled cheese board cannot sit in a courier depot overnight, and a $900 e-bike should not travel with a stranger. Use this matrix as a starting point.

Product typeOrders under $30$30 to $100Over $100
Small, sturdy, not perishable (books, cosmetics, gifts)Pickup, courierPickup, courierPickup, courier with signature
Chilled or perishable (deli, bakery, flowers)Pickup onlyPickup, own van on set daysPickup, own van, same-day app for urgent gifts
Bulky or heavy (plants, compost, furniture)Pickup onlyPickup, own van with a feeOwn van, pickup with loading help
High value (bikes, electronics, jewelry)Pickup, courierPickup, courier with signaturePickup with ID check, own van with handover
Needs setup or fitting (bikes, appliances)PickupPickupPickup, own van with setup at the door

Two patterns stand out. First, pickup fits every row, which is why it is the safest first option for any store with a counter. Second, small baskets of bulky or chilled goods rarely justify delivery at all: the $3 cost of pickup is the only cost those orders can carry.

When should you offer only one option?

Every extra option adds a checkout choice, a staff routine and a way to fail. Offer one option when any of these is true.

  • Pickup only: you have a counter with regular hours and fewer than about 10 local online orders a week. Delivery days would never fill a run, and you can add delivery once a waiting list of requests appears.
  • Own delivery only: you have no premises customers can visit, and your orders cluster in a few postal codes. Note that delivering with your own staff can make a home-based shop eligible for a Business Profile as a service-area business; our Business Profile guide explains the rule.
  • Courier only: your customers are spread thinly over a wide area and the product travels well. A van that covers 60 miles for 5 drops loses to a parcel rate every time.

And a warning about the fourth option: a same-day app should be an addition, never the only local option, unless your products sell mainly as impulse or urgent buys. With a commission on every order, your margin depends on terms you do not set.

What does each option ask of your staff and systems?

An option is only as good as the routine behind it. Before you switch one on, check that someone owns each line below.

OptionDaily routineSystem requirementSet-up guide
PickupPick, pack, label, shelve, send “ready” message, check the name at handoverStock that the website and till share, so the last item is not sold twiceClick and collect setup
Own deliveryClose orders at the cutoff, plan the run, load, deliver, record failed dropsDelivery zones with fees, minimums and cutoffs at checkoutLocal delivery zones
CourierPack, print labels, hand over at collection timeShipping rates or a carrier connectionYour carrier’s own guide
Same-day appWatch the tablet, pack within the app’s time limitMenu or catalog kept in sync with the appThe app’s set-up pack

If you sell from more than one shop or a separate stockroom, every option also needs stock counted per location, so the checkout only offers pickup where the item really is. That set-up lives in the local inventory guide.

How do you test a new option before committing to it?

Run any new option as a four-week pilot with stop rules written down in advance. That turns a gut decision into a measured one.

  1. Limit it. Own delivery to two postal codes, or pickup at one shop, or the app for one product group.
  2. Count four numbers each week: orders using the option, cost per order (from your actual hours and bills), problems (no-shows, failed drops, wrong items) and average basket.
  3. Set the stop rules before you start. Example: stop own delivery if runs average fewer than 5 drops after week three; stop pickup at a shop if more than 1 in 10 orders is never collected.
  4. Ask the staff who ran it. The driver and the counter team know which part of the routine breaks first.
  5. Decide at week four: keep, change the terms (days, fee, minimum) or drop it.

A pilot also gives you real figures for the cost table above, which beats any estimate, ours included.

What should you decide before you hire help to set it up?

A developer or agency can configure pickup and delivery in a few hours once the decisions exist. Without them, the set-up drags on and you pay for the thinking time. Write these down first:

  • Which options, for which products, from which locations.
  • Delivery days, windows, cutoffs, fees, free-delivery threshold and minimum order per zone.
  • Pickup hours, how long orders are held, and whether pickup has a fee.
  • Who sends the “ready” and “out for delivery” messages, and from which system.
  • What happens to a missed delivery or an uncollected order.

That list slots straight into the scope section of an ecommerce brief. If you have not yet chosen a platform, our Shopify vs WooCommerce comparison looks at how each handles a physical shop.

FAQ

Should I charge for local pickup?

Keep it free unless pickup orders cost you more than the margin they bring, since it is the cheapest option you have and a fee pushes customers toward delivery. If you charge, WooCommerce’s Local Pickup setting has an optional price, and the fee must show clearly at checkout.

Is free local delivery worth offering?

Only above a threshold that covers the cost. In the deli example, a delivered order costs $9.43 on a 12-drop run, and at 35% margin it takes $9.43 / 0.35 = $26.94 of basket to pay for that. Add it to the $48 average and a free-delivery threshold near $75 is the lowest that pays for itself.

Can I deliver to some postal codes and not others?

Yes. Shopify local delivery accepts a list of postal codes or a distance, and WooCommerce shipping zones can be limited to specific postal codes. The delivery zones guide shows how to draw and price them.

Do same-day delivery apps replace my own van?

Rarely for a small shop with regular local customers. The app’s cost per order grows with the basket size because of the percentage, while your van’s cost per order falls as runs fill up. Apps work best for urgent, high-margin items.

How many options should the checkout show?

Two is a good ceiling for a small store: pickup plus one delivery method. Each extra option needs its own staff routine, and a choice customers do not understand leads to wrong selections and support emails.

Should pickup and delivery have different cutoff times?

Yes, in most shops. Pickup can take orders until shortly before closing, because staff pick during quiet moments. Delivery needs an earlier cutoff so the run can be planned and loaded.

What if most of my customers live too far for my van?

Draw your van zone around the postal codes where orders cluster, offer courier delivery beyond it, and keep pickup for everyone. The van then only runs where it fills up.

What should you do next?

Fill in the cost table with your own wage rate, vehicle cost and courier quote, mark your product types in the matrix, and pick one or two options to pilot for four weeks. With those numbers in hand, the set-up itself is a short job. If you would like help turning the decision into a brief for a provider, use the MarketPulse contact form.