Local Ecommerce Consultant Checklist
You have one local consultant on your shortlist. Run these 16 pass/fail checks before you sign: listings, references, sample work, insurance, contract terms and the commissions nobody mentions.
This local ecommerce consultant checklist is for the moment after the first call, when one consultant looks right and you want to be sure before paying. It turns a good impression into checks you can verify: a listing you can look up, references you can phone, a sample you can read and contract wording you can point to.
It assumes you already know what kind of consultant you want and which format (audit, workshop or advisory hours) fits the job; if not, read ecommerce consultants near me first. Each check below gets a pass or a fail. Red rows are deal-breakers; amber rows mean ask one more question before deciding.
How should you use this checklist?
Work through it in three sittings, each short:
- Desk checks (30 minutes). Listings, website, business registration, sample work. You can do these alone.
- Reference calls (two calls of 15 minutes). Use the questions further down.
- Contract read (30 minutes). Compare the draft against the contract rows.
Scoring rule: two fails on red rows means you stop. One red fail means you raise it with the consultant in writing and only continue if the answer fixes it. Amber fails are normal; three or more of them together suggest the consultant is less organised than the first call made them look.
Keep the filled-in table. If you later hire someone else for the build, the same answers about access and ownership save time with them too.
What are the 16 checks?
| # | Check | How to verify | Pass when | Level |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Registered business | Look up the company or sole trader registration in your country’s public register | Name and address match the proposal | Red |
| 2 | Platform listing, if they claim one | Search the official directory yourself (details below) | The profile exists under the same name and matches what they told you | Red |
| 3 | Relevant sample work | Ask for an anonymised audit or plan from a similar shop | Findings are specific, ranked and sized | Red |
| 4 | Two references you can phone | Ask for names and numbers or emails of past clients | Both answer and confirm the work | Red |
| 5 | Disclosure of commissions and referral fees | Ask in writing (wording below) | A written yes with details, or a written no | Red |
| 6 | Professional liability insurance | Ask for the certificate or policy summary | Valid dates, cover type matches advice work | Amber |
| 7 | Written scope | Read the proposal | Lists what is included, what is excluded and what you receive at the end | Red |
| 8 | Fixed fee or capped hours | Read the price section | Total is fixed or has a ceiling you agree to | Amber |
| 9 | Cancellation terms | Read the contract | You can stop with notice and pay only for work done | Amber |
| 10 | Report usage rights | Read the contract | You may share the report with any provider you choose | Amber |
| 11 | Confidentiality and data handling | Read the contract | Your sales and customer data stay confidential and are deleted or returned at the end | Red |
| 12 | Limited access request | Ask what access they need | They ask for the least access the job requires, on their own named account | Red |
| 13 | Named person doing the work | Ask who writes the report | The person you met, or a named colleague you can speak to | Amber |
| 14 | Realistic timeline | Compare dates in the proposal with their current workload | Dates are specific and they explain their availability | Amber |
| 15 | Local presence where it matters | Ask about site visits | A visit is included or priced, if your problem is in the shop | Amber |
| 16 | No pressure to sign | Notice how the offer is presented | No “this price ends Friday” pressure | Amber |
How do you verify a Shopify or WooCommerce listing?
A platform listing is evidence you can check yourself. Do the search on the platform’s own site, never through a link the consultant sends, and compare names, location and the services listed.
Shopify Partner Directory
The Shopify Partner Directory lets you filter partners by service, location and price, and shows reviews, work samples and certifications on each profile. It also has an “Expert guidance” section for consultants, covering areas like business strategy, sales tax and wholesale. Partners are placed in tiers (Select, Plus, Premier and Platinum) that Shopify says reflect factors including their history of experience and proven success on Shopify. The directory also states that listed partners work independently, so a listing tells you the profile is real and gives you reviews to read; it is no guarantee from Shopify about the work.
WooCommerce
WooCommerce’s development services page lists Woo Agency Partners and says each one passes a technical and design review before being listed. You can filter by industry, services, budget, location, language and partner tier. That directory is aimed at agencies; for individual WooCommerce developers, the same page points to Codeable.
When there is no listing
Plenty of capable independent consultants are in neither directory, especially those who advise on operations or marketplaces rather than platform work. Treat check 2 as a pass when they make no listing claim. It fails only when they claim a listing that you cannot find or that differs from what they told you.
Which questions should you ask references?
A reference the consultant picked will be friendly. Good questions still get useful answers out of a friendly person, because they ask about facts instead of feelings.
- What did you hire them for, and what did you receive at the end?
- How many of their recommendations did you act on? Which ones made a difference?
- Did the final cost match the proposal? If it changed, why?
- Did they finish on the date they gave you?
- Was there anything they recommended that turned out wrong for your shop?
- Did they recommend specific apps, agencies or developers? Did they tell you whether they earned anything from those?
- How did they handle access to your store and data? Did they remove it at the end?
- Would you hire them again for the same kind of work? For a different kind?
Question 5 is the most revealing. A reference who says “nothing” to that is either very lucky or not thinking hard. A specific, small answer (“the app they suggested was too expensive for us, so we dropped it”) sounds like a real working relationship.
To get past hand-picked references, ask: “Which client from the last year would you rather I did not call, and why?” The answer to that tells you how they talk about difficult work.
What makes sample work pass or fail?
Ask for a real, anonymised piece of work: an audit, a platform comparison or a workshop summary from a shop similar in size to yours. Then judge it against four tests.
- Specific: findings point at pages, products or numbers in that client’s store.
- Ranked: it is clear which three things matter most.
- Sized: each finding has an owner and an effort estimate.
- Honest about limits: it says what was not reviewed.
A sample passes check 3 when it meets at least three of the four. Fails include a slide deck of general principles, a tool export with a logo on top, or “we cannot share client work” with nothing offered in its place. Confidentiality is a fair concern, so an anonymised or redacted sample is a fair request.
What insurance and business details should you ask for?
Advice can go wrong, and a recommendation that leads to a costly build decision is the main risk with a consultant. Professional liability insurance (called professional indemnity in some countries) covers claims arising from that advice.
Ask for three things and check the dates:
- The insurance certificate or a policy summary naming the business
- The registered business name and number that will appear on invoices
- The country and currency they invoice in, and whether tax is added
Insurance rules and norms differ by country, so MarketPulse marks this check amber, never red: a sole consultant without a policy can still be a good hire for a small workshop. For a large audit that will shape an expensive project, ask about it before signing.
Which contract terms should be in writing?
The contract rows in the checklist (7 to 11) translate into wording you can look for. Sample clauses to compare against, in plain language:
| Term | Sample wording to look for |
|---|---|
| Scope | “The consultant will review the online store, order data for the last 12 months and the fulfilment process. Out of scope: paid advertising accounts and the physical store layout.” |
| Output | “The client receives a written report with ranked findings and a review call of 60 minutes.” |
| Fee | “Fixed fee of [amount], invoiced 50% on signing and 50% on delivery of the report.” |
| Cancellation | “Either party may end the agreement with 7 days’ written notice. The client pays for work completed up to that date.” |
| Usage | “The client may use and share the report with any third party.” |
| Data | “Client data is used only for this engagement and deleted within 30 days of the final invoice.” |
| Access | “The client creates a named account for the consultant and removes it at the end.” |
The figures and wording are examples, not legal advice. If any of these points is missing from the draft, ask for it to be added; a reasonable consultant agrees to most of them in one email.
How do you spot a conflict of interest?
Consultants can earn money from the things they recommend, and that is normal in this market. Shopify’s own partner programme page tells partners they can earn on apps, themes, store builds and referrals. WooCommerce’s agency programme page mentions a referral programme for agencies in it. Earning from recommendations is fine when you know about it; the risk sits in earnings you never hear about.
Send this question in writing before you sign:
“Do you or your business receive any payment, commission, discount or referral fee from apps, plugins, themes, platforms, agencies or developers you may recommend to us? If yes, please list them. If you recommend something you earn from, please say so in the report.”
A pass is a written answer either way. Watch for these signs during the work as well:
- Every recommendation leads to one particular app or one particular agency.
- The report proposes a platform change without comparing the cost of staying.
- The consultant offers to do the build themselves before the audit is finished.
The last one is worth a closer look; whether one person can advise and build sensibly is covered in consultant vs developer.
What access should a consultant get to your store?
Give the consultant their own named login with the least access the job needs. Never share your owner password: you lose the record of who changed what, and you cannot remove one person without changing the password for everyone.
- WooCommerce: WooCommerce’s roles and capabilities documentation describes a Shop Manager role that lets someone manage the store without full Administrator access. For an audit, that is enough in most cases; WordPress’s Administrator role, per the WordPress roles documentation, has access to all administration features of the site.
- Shopify: give the consultant their own account instead of the owner login, and ask which areas of the admin the review needs.
- Analytics and ad accounts: read-only access is enough for review work.
Write the end date for access into your calendar on the day you grant it. Removing access at the end is covered with the rest of the handover in the after-launch checklist.
FAQ
Does a Shopify Partner Directory listing mean Shopify approved the consultant?
The directory says listed partners work independently, and tiers reflect factors such as experience and proven success on Shopify. Use the listing as a starting point for reviews and work samples, then run your own checks on the person.
What if the consultant has no references because they are new?
Ask for a sample of work from a previous job (employed or freelance) and offer a smaller first engagement, such as a half-day workshop. Mark check 4 as a fail and decide whether the smaller scope makes that acceptable.
Is it rude to ask about commissions?
No. It is a standard business question, and the platforms openly describe partner earnings from referrals and apps. A consultant who takes offence at it has told you something useful.
Should I check a consultant’s reviews on Google?
Yes, as one input. Read the lowest-rated reviews and how the consultant replied. A short list of reviews from a small local business is normal and no reason to fail them.
How long should vetting one consultant take?
About two hours spread over a few days: the desk checks, two reference calls and a careful read of the contract. For a workshop worth a few hundred in fees, a lighter version (checks 1, 3, 5, 7 and 12) is enough.
What if two red checks fail but I still like the consultant?
Tell them which checks failed and why, in writing, and give them the chance to fix both. If they do, rerun those rows. If they cannot, the good feeling from the first call is not enough to carry the risk.
Do I need to check insurance for a one-day workshop?
It matters less for a short session where you make the decisions in the room. For an audit or advisory work that will shape a large spend, ask for it.
What should you do next?
Copy the 16-row table, fill in the desk checks today and book the two reference calls. Send the commission question and the access question in one email, so the answers arrive together. If the red rows pass, sign; if two fail, thank the consultant and move to the next name.
If something in the answers looks odd and you want a second opinion before signing, describe it through the MarketPulse contact form. We help owners prepare hiring decisions; we do not vet or rank consultants ourselves.